The RecordExhibit 35
Suing the Wall Street Journal over an Epstein birthday letter
Pending means: In court or under criminal investigation right now.
After the Journal reported that a 2003 birthday note bearing Trump's name and a sketch of a naked woman was in an album made for Epstein's 50th birthday, Trump sued the paper and Rupert Murdoch.
Updated Nov 4, 2026: On Oct. 31 Judge Gayles dismissed Trump's refiled suit with prejudice for failing to plead actual malice. Status unchanged (Pending) while an appeal is possible.
Earlier changes to this entry (1)
- Updated Oct 11, 2026: On June 10 the Journal asked Judge Darrin Gayles to dismiss Trump's refiled suit with prejudice and sought fees under Florida's anti-SLAPP law; no ruling has been reported. Status unchanged (Pending).
What happened
Trump said he had personally warned Murdoch not to print the story. The note was among dozens collected by Ghislaine Maxwell. Congress later released the letter after subpoenaing it from Epstein's estate.
Where it stands
Judge Darrin Gayles dismissed the suit in April 2026, finding Trump hadn't plausibly alleged actual malice, the legal standard public figures must meet; he did not decide whether the letter is genuine. Trump refiled in May, again seeking at least $10 billion.
On June 10 the Journal asked Judge Darrin Gayles in Miami to dismiss the refiled suit for good, arguing that the new allegations repackage the failure-to-investigate theory he had already rejected, and sought legal fees under Florida's law against lawsuits meant to silence speech; a Trump spokesperson called the refiled complaint a powerhouse lawsuit.
On Oct. 31, 2026, Gayles dismissed the refiled suit with prejudice, which bars Trump from suing again over the same claims, finding that he again failed to plead actual malice and calling his allegations conclusory and vague; he wrote that Trump was 'grasping at straws'. No appeal had been reported by Nov. 4.
The administration's side
Trump says the letter is fake, that he doesn't draw pictures, and that the words aren't his. His amended complaint says the paper recklessly disregarded whether its story was true.
Sources
Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/wsj/