The wire About & Methodology All entries

The RecordExhibit 34

Justice system

Fired the prosecutor who convicted Ghislaine Maxwell

Ruled unlawfulUpdated Oct 28, 2026

Ruled unlawful means: A court ruled against it. Some rulings are on appeal.

Maurene Comey, who prosecuted Epstein, Maxwell and Sean Combs, was fired with no explanation beyond a memo citing the president's Article II powers.

Updated Oct 28, 2026: On Oct. 26 Judge Jesse Furman ruled the firing unlawful under civil service law, the separation of powers, the APA and due process, and ordered her reinstated with back pay to December 2025. The department says it will appeal. Status changed from Pending to Ruled.

What happened

She is James Comey's daughter. Her firing came days after the Epstein reversal. Her lawsuit says she was fired solely or substantially because of who her father is.

Where it stands

On Oct. 26, 2026, Judge Jesse Furman in Manhattan ruled the firing unlawful. He held that the attorney general may remove an assistant U.S. attorney only in the way and for the reasons the Civil Service Reform Act allows, and that the firing also violated the separation of powers, the Administrative Procedure Act and her due process rights. He rejected the department's argument that line prosecutors can be fired at will, noting that the Supreme Court decisions it relied on do not cover inferior officers, and ordered her reinstated with back pay from her July 2025 firing to December 2025, when she effectively resigned by accepting a private-sector job.

The reports we opened do not say whether it is a final judgment. The Justice Department says it will appeal. In April 2026 Furman had let the suit go forward in federal court, rejecting the department's bid to send it to an administrative board.

The administration's side

The administration cites the president's constitutional power to remove executive branch employees. In court the Justice Department argued that prosecutors handling criminal cases exercise core presidential power and can be removed for any reason, relying on Trump v. Slaughter and Trump v. United States, and that civil service protections are an unconstitutional intrusion on that power. After the ruling a spokesperson said, 'The Department disagrees with this decision and will appeal in due course.'

Sources

See it in the timeline

Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/mcomey/