The wire About & Methodology All entries

The RecordExhibit 36

Justice system

Firing court-picked prosecutors to keep his own picks in charge

Ruled unlawfulUpdated Oct 28, 2026

Ruled unlawful means: A court ruled against it. Some rulings are on appeal.

When New Jersey's federal judges appointed a U.S. attorney in July 2025, after the legal time limit ran out for Trump's interim pick, his former personal lawyer Alina Habba, the Justice Department fired the court's choice and used a chain of maneuvers to keep Habba in charge.

Updated Oct 28, 2026: On Oct. 27 Judge J. Michael Seabright ruled that Bill Essayli is unlawfully serving as the de facto U.S. attorney in Los Angeles; the order waits on the government's request for a stay pending appeal. Status unchanged (Ruled).

Earlier changes to this entry (1)
  • Updated Oct 6, 2026: On Oct. 4 the Ninth Circuit temporarily put on hold the Oct. 1 order reinstating Seattle's U.S. attorney, Roger Rogoff, while the Justice Department appeals. The entry now says the Oct. 1 order was a preliminary injunction.

What happened

Federal law lets an interim U.S. attorney serve 120 days; after that, the local federal court can appoint someone until the Senate confirms a nominee. The administration used similar workarounds to keep its chosen prosecutor, Sigal Chattah, running the Nevada office. In Seattle, Trump fired court-appointed U.S. attorney Roger Rogoff minutes after he was sworn in on July 15, 2026.

Where it stands

Courts have repeatedly ruled against the workarounds. Judge Matthew Brann, a Pennsylvania federal judge assigned to the New Jersey case, ruled in August 2025 that Habba was serving unlawfully; a panel of the Third Circuit Court of Appeals agreed on Dec. 1, 2025, and she resigned a week later. In Nevada, U.S. District Judge David Campbell ruled in September 2025 that Chattah could not lawfully serve as acting U.S. attorney, and a panel of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld him on Aug. 17, 2026. The Justice Department has asked the Supreme Court to step in.

On Oct. 1, 2026, in the first ruling of its kind, Chief Judge Stanley Bastian of the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Washington, who took the case after Seattle's federal judges recused themselves, held that a president cannot fire a court-appointed U.S. attorney and ordered Rogoff reinstated. That ruling is a preliminary injunction, not a final judgment, and the Justice Department appealed to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.

On Oct. 4 the Ninth Circuit put the reinstatement on hold with an administrative stay, a short pause to keep things as they were while it considers a longer one; it did not rule on whether the firing was legal. Rogoff said he would not oppose a stay during the appeal so the case can be decided quickly. He remains out of the office for now.

On Oct. 27, 2026, Judge J. Michael Seabright ruled that Bill Essayli is unlawfully serving as the de facto U.S. attorney in Los Angeles: shortly before his 120 days as acting U.S. attorney ran out he was named first assistant, and he has in practice kept running the office, an arrangement the judge called identical to the one used for Chattah in Nevada. The order will not take effect until the court rules on the government's request to pause it during an appeal. In October 2025 Seabright had barred Essayli from overseeing several criminal cases.

The administration's side

The Justice Department says the president keeps the power to fire any U.S. attorney, including one appointed by a court, and will appeal the Seattle ruling. In New Jersey it argued the attorney general could lawfully delegate the office's powers to Habba. It does not dispute that courts can make temporary appointments. Essayli said he disagrees with the Oct. 27 order, that the president and attorney general have every right to select supervisors, and that the question will be decided by the Supreme Court.

Sources

See it in the timeline

Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/usattorneys/