The wire About & Methodology All entries

The RecordExhibit 44

Health & science

Firing every vaccine adviser and the CDC director

CriticizedUpdated Oct 7, 2026Checked Oct 16, 2026

Criticized means: Legal, or a policy choice, but widely condemned.

HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. fired all 17 members of the CDC's vaccine advisory committee, and the CDC director was fired after 29 days on the job.

Updated Oct 7, 2026: On Oct. 6 a First Circuit panel heard the government's appeal of the order blocking 13 of Kennedy's committee appointments; the chief judge questioned the order's reasoning, and there is no ruling yet. Status unchanged (Criticized).

What happened

Susan Monarez testified under oath that she was fired for refusing to pre-approve the new committee's vaccine recommendations without seeing the data, and for refusing to fire career vaccine officials without cause.

Where it stands

On March 16, 2026, Judge Brian Murphy found that Kennedy's remaking of the vaccine committee likely violated federal law. He put the appointments of 13 of the new members on hold, along with the votes the remade panel had taken (see the entry on the childhood vaccine schedule). The ruling is preliminary.

The government appealed the part blocking the appointments, and a First Circuit panel heard arguments on Oct. 6, 2026; Chief Judge David Barron questioned whether the order explained why blocking the appointees was justified, and the panel has not ruled. The committee has not met since the ruling. The firings also drew bipartisan concern at Senate hearings.

The administration's side

The White House said Monarez was not aligned with the president's Make America Healthy Again agenda.

Sources

See it in the timeline

Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/cdc/