The RecordExhibit 45
Blowing up boats, and the survivors
Alleged means: Serious, credible accusations of illegality that no court or watchdog has decided yet.
U.S. forces began destroying alleged drug boats in the Caribbean and Pacific with no trials and little public evidence. The AP counts at least 235 people killed in 70 strikes since September 2025.
Updated Oct 28, 2026: On Oct. 27 Judge Engelmayer refused to suspend his order and gave the government 14 days to tell him confidentially who has had access to the legal memo on the strikes. Status unchanged (Alleged).
Earlier changes to this entry (2)
- Updated Oct 28, 2026: Southern Command said an Oct. 27 strike in the eastern Pacific killed five people; a tracker cited by Al Jazeera puts the campaign's death toll at about 243. Status unchanged (Alleged).
- Updated Oct 8, 2026: On Oct. 4 a strike in the Caribbean killed four people. The AP now counts at least 235 people killed in 70 strikes since September 2025. Status unchanged (Alleged).
What happened
After the very first strike, two men clung to the burning wreckage for roughly 45 minutes before a second strike killed them. The Washington Post reported Defense Secretary Hegseth had given a verbal order to kill everybody; he said he didn't personally see survivors and blamed the fog of war. Across the campaign, 23 survivors are presumed dead. Drug policy experts say the results are mixed, since smugglers have many other routes into the country.
On Oct. 4, 2026, Southern Command said a strike on a boat in the Caribbean killed four people; the military released a video but no evidence that the boat carried drugs. On Oct. 27, 2026, Southern Command said a strike on a boat in the eastern Pacific killed five people it called narco-terrorists, citing 'confirmed intelligence' but giving no specifics; Al Jazeera, citing the Washington Office on Latin America's tracker, put the death toll since September 2025 at about 243.
Where it stands
Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International and UN experts call the strikes extrajudicial killings, and military law experts say killing shipwreck survivors breaks the laws of war. In September, UN special rapporteur Ben Saul wrote that there are reasonable grounds to believe the strikes amount to crimes against humanity.
In May 2026 the Pentagon's inspector general opened an investigation into how strike targets are chosen, approved and assessed. Relatives of two Trinidadian men killed in an October 2025 strike have sued for wrongful death. In a bipartisan defense bill, Congress withheld part of Hegseth's travel budget until unedited strike video is handed over.
On Sept. 30, 2026, Judge Paul Engelmayer rejected most of the administration's reasons for keeping secret the 40-page Justice Department memo it cites as the legal basis for the strikes, finding the Pentagon has treated the memo as its effective law, and ordered it turned over for his private review by Oct. 14.
On Oct. 27, 2026, Engelmayer lifted a temporary pause he had granted on Oct. 8, refused the government's request to suspend his order, and gave it 14 days to tell him confidentially who has had access to the memo, when and for what purpose; he has not yet decided whether the memo can stay secret.
The administration's side
The administration told Congress the U.S. is in an armed conflict with cartels, that those killed are unlawful combatants, and that a classified Justice Department opinion authorizes the strikes. Trump says the strikes have stopped 97% of the drugs coming in by sea. Adm. Frank Bradley, who oversaw the first strike, has denied that Hegseth ordered troops to kill everybody.
Sources
- States Newsroom via Minnesota Reformer
- CNN via Madison365
- The Intercept
- AFP via Khaleej Times
- USNI News
- AFP via Malay Mail
- Washington Times
- The Hill (inspector general)
- The Hill (Sept. 20)
- The Hill via Yahoo
- Law&Crime via Yahoo
- ACLU
- AP via ABC News (Oct. 4 strike)
- Al Jazeera (Oct. 27 strike)
- EFE via Infobae (Oct. 27 order)
Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/boats/