The wire About & Methodology All entries

The RecordExhibit 169

Immigration & policing

Arresting immigrants without warrants, then documenting the arrests afterward

Ruled unlawfulAdded Nov 14, 2026

Ruled unlawful means: A court ruled against it. Some rulings are on appeal.

Federal judges in Colorado, Oregon and New York have found that immigration agents made civil arrests without warrants and without the individual finding of escape risk that federal law requires for a warrantless arrest, and have ordered them to stop.

What happened

Federal law lets an immigration officer arrest someone without a warrant only when the officer has reason to believe the person is in the country unlawfully and is likely to escape before a warrant can be obtained. Plaintiffs in several states say agents in enforcement sweeps arrested people they came across and produced the paperwork later, a practice critics call 'arrest first, justify later.'

In Oregon, the plaintiffs included Victor Cruz Gamez, 56, who has lived in the U.S. since 1999 and says he was pulled over driving home from work in October 2025 and held for three weeks despite a valid work permit and a pending visa application; Judge Mustafa Kasubhai called agents' conduct in Oregon, including drawing guns on people during civil immigration detentions, 'violent and brutal.'

In Colorado, the judge held a two-day evidentiary hearing in March 2026 on whether agents had kept making unlawful warrantless arrests after his order. In New York, Judge Gary Brown's Oct. 5, 2026 ruling on the warrantless arrest of Angel Almonte and a U.S. citizen in the Bronx, in which he found agents prepared a false warrant afterward, is described in Exhibit 57. When the practice began cannot be pinned to a day, so this entry is dated to the first injunction found. Related: the re-arrests of people judges ordered freed (Exhibit 168) and courthouse arrests (Exhibit 115).

Where it stands

Ruled, on preliminary orders. On Nov. 25, 2025, Judge R. Brooke Jackson in Colorado issued a preliminary injunction barring warrantless arrests without an individual, pre-arrest finding of escape risk, and on May 12, 2026 he found that the government had materially violated it and ordered officers retrained within 45 days or barred from warrantless arrests in the state; the government's appeal is before the Tenth Circuit, where briefing was complete by Aug. 31 and no ruling was found.

On Feb. 4, 2026, Judge Mustafa Kasubhai in Oregon issued a similar preliminary injunction, later certified a class, and ordered agents to document every warrantless arrest; the government has appealed to the Ninth Circuit, and on Nov. 2, 2026 Kasubhai concluded that the government had inaccurately reported its warrantless arrests under his order.

The AP reported in February that a court in Washington, D.C. had issued a similar ruling. In the Eastern District of New York, Judge Gary Brown, a Trump appointee, has ordered that ICE obtain a valid warrant before any civil immigration arrest in the district unless the person is likely to escape first.

On Nov. 9, 2026, Judge Sanket Bulsara barred Assistant U.S. Attorney Thomas Price from a related case after finding that a Nov. 4 letter Price signed, telling the court Brown's injunction protected only one person, was made in bad faith and was a deliberate attempt to mislead the court; Bulsara ordered two other government lawyers on the letter to explain their roles under oath by Nov. 16. None of these is a final ruling.

The administration's side

ICE acting director Todd Lyons's memo, issued days before the Oregon ruling, tells agents not to arrest without an administrative warrant unless they have probable cause that the person is in the country unlawfully and is likely to escape before a warrant can be obtained. The government has appealed the Colorado and Oregon injunctions; in its Ninth Circuit brief it asks the court to vacate the Oregon injunction, arguing that the plaintiffs lack standing and that the order improperly puts the district court in charge of supervising all warrantless immigration arrests in the state.

DHS did not comment on the Oregon ruling to the AP. At the Nov. 9 hearing the head of the civil division of the U.S. attorney's office asked for time to review the transcript and did not respond to the misconduct finding.

Sources

See it in the timeline

Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/warrantless/