The RecordExhibit 47
Suing 30 states for their voters' private data
Ruled unlawful means: A court ruled against it. Some rulings are on appeal.
The Justice Department demanded complete voter registration lists, including birth dates, driver's license numbers and partial Social Security numbers, from nearly every state, then sued the states that refused, starting with Oregon and Maine in September 2025.
Updated Oct 17, 2026: The Justice Department appealed the Oct. 9 ruling vacating its voter list maintenance policy.
Earlier changes to this entry (3)
- Updated Oct 16, 2026: On Oct. 15 the League of Women Voters, EPIC and LULAC sued Homeland Security, alleging it obtained voter files from at least 47 states, including states that refused the Justice Department, and asking that the data be deleted. Status unchanged (Ruled).
- Updated Oct 10, 2026: On Oct. 9 Judge Sparkle Sooknanan in Washington vacated the department's policy of demanding state voter rolls and checking them against the SAVE citizenship database, finding no legal authority for it and violations of the Administrative Procedure Act and the Privacy Act. Status unchanged (Ruled).
- Corrected Oct 6, 2026: The entry said judges in 11 states had ruled against the department. That count was out of date: by Aug. 17, 2026, the Minnesota Reformer counted 23 losses and no wins, in 22 states and Washington, D.C. The entry also now notes the department's appeals and Oklahoma's settlement.
What happened
Several states offered the public, redacted versions of their lists; the department insisted on copies with personal information. It has now sued 30 states and Washington, D.C. Asked whether the data would be run through the federal citizenship-check system, a department spokesperson said only that it would be screened for ineligible voters. Maine's secretary of state said the department had never asked states for voter data like this before.
Where it stands
Federal judges have ruled against the department in state after state, and these are final rulings dismissing its lawsuits, not preliminary orders. When Judge Katherine Menendez of the U.S. District Court in Minnesota threw out the suit against Minnesota on Aug. 17, 2026, writing that the government seemed to think it could use a civil lawsuit as a 'fishing expedition', the Minnesota Reformer counted 23 losses and no wins for the department: 22 states and Washington, D.C. The judges include a Trump appointee in Maine, and a California judge called the demand unprecedented and illegal.
The department has appealed a number of the dismissals, including Minnesota's according to Democracy Docket's case tracker. On June 24, 2026, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld Michigan's win, the department's first loss at that level and so far the only appeal decided; the full court then declined to rehear it.
By early October a University of Wisconsin law school tracker counted 26 of the department's 31 lawsuits dismissed by district courts, with most of the dismissals on appeal. One state, Oklahoma, settled by agreeing to hand over its data. The latest ruling came on Sept. 30, when a judge ruled Georgia could comply with federal law by providing a redacted list. We found no ruling in the department's favor.
On Oct. 9, 2026, U.S. District Judge Sparkle Sooknanan in Washington, ruling in a lawsuit by Common Cause and individual voters, vacated the department's policy of demanding the lists and running them through the federal SAVE citizenship database to flag voters for removal. In a 78-page decision she found that the department had no legal authority to demand the lists, compare them against citizenship databases and push removals, that the policy violated the Administrative Procedure Act and the Privacy Act, and that the databases could contain inaccuracies, including outdated records for naturalized citizens.
She wrote that the policy 'represents the federal government's attempt to decide who gets to vote', a power Congress left to the states, and that the court 'vacates a policy that has removed United States citizens from the voter rolls'. CBS News reported that the ruling covers the files the department already received from the 18 states that complied as well as the files still being litigated. Federal law bars systematic removals in the 90 days before a federal election, which limits what the ruling changes before Nov. 3.
The Justice Department appealed Judge Sooknanan's Oct. 9 decision to the D.C. Circuit on Oct. 16, according to Democracy Docket. The ruling has not been overturned in the reporting opened. On Oct. 15, 2026, the League of Women Voters, the Electronic Privacy Information Center and LULAC sued Homeland Security in federal court in Washington, alleging that it obtained voter files from at least 47 states, including states that refused the Justice Department, ran a secretive review of the data with a policy of combining it with commercial datasets, and violated federal law and the privacy rights of millions of Americans; they ask the court to declare the collection illegal, block it and order the data deleted. DHS did not immediately comment. The department's new suit against California over 20,000 mail ballots is Exhibit 161.
The administration's side
The department says federal civil rights and voting laws entitle it to the full lists so it can check whether states are properly removing ineligible voters, and that its requests are legal. After the Oct. 9 ruling the department said it was reviewing the decision.
Sources
- AP via WCAX
- NPR via WLRN
- NPR via WNIN
- CBS News (Oregon)
- CBS News (Maine, Wisconsin)
- Votebeat
- Atlanta News First
- Brennan Center tracker
- Minnesota Reformer via KAXE (Minnesota dismissal, count)
- WCCO Radio (appeals, Oklahoma settlement)
- Minnesota Secretary of State
- Democracy Docket (Minnesota case tracker)
- Congressional Research Service (Sixth Circuit ruling)
- State Democracy Research Initiative tracker
- Al Jazeera (Oct. 9 ruling)
- CBS News (Oct. 9 ruling)
- AP via WCAX (voter groups' lawsuit)
- Democracy Docket
Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/voterrolls/