The wire About & Methodology All entries

The RecordExhibit 129

Immigration & policing

Fines of up to $1.8 million for immigrants who stayed after a deportation order

Ruled unlawfulUpdated Oct 16, 2026

Ruled unlawful means: A court ruled against it. Some rulings are on appeal.

On Oct. 5, 2026, a federal judge in Boston blocked the administration's policy of fining immigrants $998 a day, up to $1.8 million, for failing to leave the country after a final deportation order. He said the fines were imposed unlawfully.

Updated Oct 16, 2026: On Oct. 14 DHS and the Justice Department published a final rule making the fast-track fine process permanent, days after the judge halted the interim version; it adds only a late-appeal allowance for mail delays. Status unchanged (Ruled).

Earlier changes to this entry (1)
  • Corrected Oct 7, 2026: The entry was missing two facts from coverage of the Oct. 5 ruling: the judge also found the fine process was adopted without the public comment the law requires, and DHS said in July it had issued more than 103,000 fines totaling about $84 billion.

What happened

The administration began levying the $998-a-day fines last year (the reports we opened do not give the exact date the policy began, so this entry is dated to the ruling) and applied them retroactively for up to five years, which is how the maximum reaches $1.8 million. As recently as July 2026, Homeland Security said it had issued more than 103,000 fines totaling about $84 billion since Trump returned to office.

Two of the immigrants who were fined, joined by the Immigrant Legal Resource Center, filed a class action in 2025. They challenged the policy and what they described as a practice by ICE of issuing fines on boilerplate forms without assessing whether a person's failure to leave was willful or voluntary. In one case reported by CBS News, a mother from Honduras living in Florida was fined more than $1.82 million over a removal order issued in 2005.

Where it stands

U.S. District Judge George O'Toole in Boston ruled on Oct. 5, 2026, in the class action. Reuters reported that he held the fines were unlawful and violated the Administrative Procedure Act because the forms lacked specific allegations explaining why a person's conduct warranted a penalty. He wrote that the plaintiffs were already in a precarious financial position and that collecting the fines would likely drive them into insolvency, which is why he halted the penalty policies.

The reports we opened do not say whether the order is preliminary or final, and no appeal had been reported when this entry was written. Reuters also reported that O'Toole found the administration broke rulemaking requirements when it adopted its streamlined fine process in July 2025 without letting the public comment, and that Homeland Security said in July 2026 it had issued more than 103,000 fines totaling about $84 billion since Trump returned to office.

On Oct. 14, 2026, Homeland Security and the Justice Department published a final rule in the Federal Register, effective the same day, that makes the June 2025 interim rule permanent with one change: ICE may accept a late appeal when a person documents a mail delay beyond their control. The rule keeps the streamlined process in which an officer issues a written decision and order, the person has 15 business days to appeal to a supervisory officer who decides on the written record within 45 days, and the Board of Immigration Appeals no longer reviews the penalties; it says further procedures 'would not enhance the accuracy, fairness, or reliability of the process', that it authorizes no wage garnishment or asset seizure, and that most failure-to-depart fines will be rescinded for people who leave through the CBP Home app.

Immigration Analytics, a specialist site, notes that the final rule may answer the court's objection to skipping public comment but not its finding that fines were issued without individual willfulness findings; it dates Judge O'Toole's order to Sept. 30, with news reports on Oct. 6, while the reports this entry was built from dated the ruling Oct. 5.

The administration's side

Homeland Security had no immediate comment on the ruling, Reuters reported. Asked earlier by CBS News about a $1.82 million fine, an ICE spokesperson said people who violate immigration law and do not comply with a removal order face legal consequences such as fines, and that the best option is to obey the law and leave.

A DHS spokesperson urged people to use the CBP Home app to leave on their own. In the Oct. 14 final rule the departments said the immigration law allows civil penalties against people who fail to depart and that additional procedures would not make the process more accurate, fair or reliable.

Sources

See it in the timeline

Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/migrantfines/