The RecordExhibit 17
Disaster aid slowed, denied and split along party lines
Alleged means: Serious, credible accusations of illegality that no court or watchdog has decided yet.
Trump halted new hazard-mitigation grants and has rejected disaster requests from Democratic-led states at a record rate.
Updated Oct 16, 2026: Capitol News Illinois reported on Oct. 16 that Illinois's denied August storm request put damage at $27.6 million against FEMA's $24.9 million statewide standard; FEMA did not explain the denial and Gov. Pritzker is appealing. Status unchanged (Alleged).
Earlier changes to this entry (3)
- Updated Oct 11, 2026: Added E&E News's July 29 report, from state records, that FEMA and NOAA had validated damage above federal thresholds in four Northeastern states before the president denied their February snowstorm requests. FEMA says snow-prone states should handle snow removal. Status unchanged (Alleged).
- Updated Oct 10, 2026: On Oct. 8 FEMA denied Illinois's request for a disaster declaration for August storms in eight counties, saying only that assistance was not warranted. The governor plans to appeal, and a Republican congressman objected too. Status unchanged (Alleged).
- Updated Oct 6, 2026: A July 2026 Associated Press analysis of FEMA data found Trump approved 80% of disaster requests from Republican governors and about 60% from Democratic governors, and that decisions are taking longer. Status unchanged (Alleged).
What happened
He is the first president in at least three decades to deny governors' requests for mitigation funding. Politico found he rejected aid for Democratic-run states at the highest rate in FEMA's 47-year history, including four blue states denied on the same day six red states were approved. A rule requiring the Homeland Security secretary to personally sign off on spending over $100,000 left more than $14 billion stuck in the pipeline.
Where it stands
The Brennan Center calls the FEMA cuts arbitrary and unlawful. In a separate lawsuit by 20 states, Judge Richard Stearns in Massachusetts ruled on Dec. 11, 2025, that FEMA's cancellation of a disaster-preparedness grant program, Building Resilient Infrastructure and Communities (BRIC), was unlawful, though he stopped short of ordering money released for specific projects. That ruling now has its own entry (Exhibit 113).
In late May 2026 two House Democrats, Bennie Thompson and Timothy Kennedy, asked the Government Accountability Office to examine the criteria FEMA uses in recommending disaster declarations; the office confirmed it had received the request. No court has ruled on whether the disaster denials were political.
In July 2026 an Associated Press analysis of FEMA data found that Trump had approved 80% of disaster requests from Republican governors but only about 60% from Democratic governors, a wider gap between states that backed him and states that did not than under any other president, and that decisions were taking weeks or months. A batch of denials that month included Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York and Rhode Island, which had sought aid after a February snowstorm.
Records obtained by Politico's E&E News through open-records requests, reported on July 29, show that FEMA and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration had validated damage in all four states above the federal thresholds before the president denied them, in Rhode Island's case about nine times its $2.1 million threshold; the four states sought $227 million in all, and E&E News found that presidents since George W. Bush had approved every state snowstorm request that met FEMA's standards except one. FEMA did not say whether it disputed the states' figures.
On Oct. 8, 2026, FEMA denied Illinois's request for a major disaster declaration for August storms in eight counties, including Cook, Champaign and McLean; Administrator Cameron Hamilton wrote that assistance was 'not warranted', without giving a reason. Gov. JB Pritzker said the state will appeal and that damage should be judged by the same objective standards whatever the state, and Republican Rep. Darin LaHood said he was deeply disappointed and would call Hamilton directly.
On Oct. 16 Capitol News Illinois reported that the state's Sept. 15 request put damage in the eight counties at $27.6 million against FEMA's statewide standard of $24.9 million, and at $5.95 per capita against the $1.94 FEMA requires for Illinois, with 4,519 homes damaged and 46 destroyed; four of the eight counties met their local thresholds, and the state argued an in-person assessment of Cook County would lift it above its $18.6 million threshold, while FEMA assessed public assistance damage virtually.
A FEMA spokesperson did not explain the denial and said the agency 'is required to review each request closely' under the Stafford Act. The same report cited a Politico analysis finding that Democratic-led states have had 23% of their disaster requests granted in Trump's second term, against 89% for Republican-led states. Pritzker is appealing.
The administration's side
The White House says there is no politicization in the president's disaster decisions. After the BRIC ruling, FEMA said it had not terminated the program and called the judge an activist. Trump's nominee to lead FEMA has pledged faster decisions and objective, fair reviews of disaster requests. On the snowstorm denials, FEMA said federal aid is reserved for truly extraordinary events and that snow-prone states should handle routine snow removal themselves, and a White House spokesperson said the president's disaster decisions are not politicized.
Sources
Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/fema/