The RecordExhibit 51
Prosecuting the president's critics
Mixed rulings means: Courts have ruled both ways on parts of it.
After Trump publicly pressed his attorney general, the Justice Department indicted former FBI Director James Comey, New York Attorney General Letitia James and former adviser John Bolton.
Updated Oct 28, 2026: On Oct. 27 a federal grand jury in Washington declined to indict Cassidy Hutchinson over her Jan. 6 committee testimony. Status unchanged (Mixed).
Earlier changes to this entry (3)
- Updated Oct 28, 2026: Unsealed records show prosecutors charged James Comey a third time on Oct. 5, by criminal information, with transmitting national defense information to a reporter in 2016. He denies it and has moved to dismiss the case as untimely. Status unchanged (Mixed).
- Updated Oct 12, 2026: Now records the Justice Department's criminal investigation, opened in May 2026, into whether E. Jean Carroll lied in a 2022 deposition about funding for her suit against Trump; no charges reported. Also points to the Oct. 12 search of Rep. Ilhan Omar's home (Watch 20). Status unchanged (Mixed).
- Updated Oct 10, 2026: On Oct. 8 CBS News reported that the Justice Department's Civil Rights Division is presenting evidence to a grand jury on whether Cassidy Hutchinson, the former White House aide who testified against Trump before the Jan. 6 committee, lied to Congress. No charges yet. Status unchanged (Mixed).
What happened
Career prosecutors had doubted the evidence against Comey and James. The U.S. attorney who declined to charge them resigned under threat of firing and was replaced by Lindsey Halligan, a former Trump personal lawyer. Asked who was next, Trump said there would be others.
In May 2026 the Justice Department also opened a criminal investigation into whether E. Jean Carroll, the writer who won two civil verdicts against Trump for sexual abuse and defamation, committed perjury in a 2022 deposition in which she said she had no outside funding for her lawsuit; the investor Reid Hoffman was later revealed to have helped fund it.
CNN first reported the inquiry on May 27, and the New York Times reported that the U.S. attorney in Chicago, Andrew Boutros, opened it. Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche, who was one of Trump's lawyers on the Carroll appeals, was reported to have recused himself. Carroll denies lying, and no charges have been reported.
Separately, on Oct. 12, 2026, Homeland Security agents searched the home of Rep. Ilhan Omar, a critic of the administration's immigration enforcement, three weeks before her election; that story is on the Watchlist as Watch 20.
Where it stands
In November 2025 Senior U.S. District Judge Cameron Currie threw out the Comey and James indictments after ruling that Halligan was unlawfully appointed. She dismissed them without prejudice, which ended those cases but left room for new charges. The administration appealed to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, where a three-judge panel heard arguments on Sept. 15, 2026; it has not ruled. Prosecutors also tried twice to get a new indictment of James, and grand juries in Norfolk and Alexandria declined both times.
In April 2026 Comey was indicted again, in North Carolina, on charges that an Instagram photo of seashells spelling out '86 47' threatened the president. His motions to dismiss it as vindictive are pending, and his arraignment has been pushed to January 2027. Bolton's case was different in kind: he pleaded guilty in June 2026 to illegally keeping classified material.
A separate Justice Department investigation in the Southern District of Florida, known as the 'grand conspiracy' probe and aimed at people NBC News describes as Trump's perceived political enemies, has produced no charges. Its leader, Joe diGenova, resigned in September 2026. NBC reported that department leaders felt it was moving too slowly and that it is expected to continue, with prosecutors seeking grand jury testimony from former officials.
On Oct. 8, 2026, CBS News reported, citing two sources, that federal prosecutors have been presenting evidence to a grand jury in Washington on whether Cassidy Hutchinson, the former aide to White House chief of staff Mark Meadows whose 2022 testimony to the House Jan. 6 committee was among the most damaging accounts of Trump's conduct that day, lied to Congress.
The investigation is being run by the department's Civil Rights Division rather than the U.S. attorney's office, which the sources called unusual, and the referral reportedly came from House Republicans. Punchbowl News first reported the grand jury activity, and the Washington Examiner confirmed through a source that the department is investigating her. No charges have been filed, and CBS could not determine which parts of her testimony are under scrutiny; one part of her account, a secondhand story that Trump lunged at the steering wheel of his vehicle on Jan. 6, was contradicted by his driver's sworn testimony.
On Oct. 26, 2026, newly unsealed records showed that prosecutors had filed a criminal information against James Comey under seal on Oct. 5, accusing him of transmitting national defense information and conspiring to do so by directing FBI staff in 2016 to speak with a New York Times reporter about a story on Yahoo email surveillance. It is the third criminal case against him this term and was filed without a grand jury.
The department says filing it within 10 years of the conduct preserves its ability to seek an indictment; Comey's lawyers say the five-year deadline has passed and have moved to dismiss. Comey denies the charges and called the case an 'appalling abuse' of the Justice Department.
The same day, a judge ruled that the firing of his daughter, Maurene Comey, was unlawful (Exhibit 34). On Oct. 27, 2026, a federal grand jury in Washington declined to indict Cassidy Hutchinson; it was disclosed at a hearing on another matter, and the Washington Post first reported it. Hutchinson stands by her testimony, and the department did not comment.
The administration's side
Trump says it isn't about revenge, calling Comey a dirty cop and arguing the conduct can't be allowed to go on. Prosecutors say the seashell post was a threat against the president and that Comey hasn't shown the people who decided to charge him had improper motives.
The Justice Department has not commented on the Hutchinson investigation. On the Oct. 5 information the department said it filed a 'waiverless criminal information' to toll the statute of limitations, a practice it says several appeals courts have approved, and that it will not comment further on an ongoing investigation.
Sources
- The Advocate
- The Hill via Yahoo
- WION
- NBC News
- MS NOW
- Al Jazeera
- CBS News (appeal)
- Fox News (appeal)
- NBC News (Florida investigation)
- MS NOW (appeal argument)
- NBC News (appeal)
- CBS News (Hutchinson grand jury)
- Washington Examiner (Hutchinson investigation)
- Time (Carroll investigation)
- ABC News (Comey information unsealed)
- Forbes (Comey information unsealed)
- ABC News (Hutchinson not indicted)
- CBS News (Hutchinson not indicted)
Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/enemies/