The wire About & Methodology All entries

The RecordExhibit 144

Checks & balances

Felling 430 trees at a century-old public golf course over a holiday weekend, in the middle of a lawsuit

Ruled unlawfulUpdated Nov 14, 2026

Ruled unlawful means: A court ruled against it. Some rulings are on appeal.

On Saturday, Oct. 10, 2026, the National Park Service cut down hundreds of mature trees at East Potomac Golf Links, a public course in Washington that opened in the 1920s and that the administration plans to rebuild as a championship venue, a day after telling the judge hearing a lawsuit against the overhaul that the work was about to begin. On Oct. 12 the judge halted further cutting and said the government had lost its credibility with her.

Updated Nov 14, 2026: On Nov. 7 Judge Reyes said she intends to appoint former U.S. attorney Jessie Liu as special master to examine whether government lawyers misled the court. Status unchanged (Ruled).

Earlier changes to this entry (6)
  • Updated Nov 4, 2026: On Oct. 30 Judge Reyes opened an inquiry into whether officials misled the court and required 10 days' notice before closing the course; the government appealed both orders. Status unchanged (Ruled).
  • Updated Oct 28, 2026: The administration appealed the Oct. 26 preliminary injunction on Oct. 27. A Justice Department filing on Oct. 28 said Interior was developing a plan to close the course by Nov. 15.
  • Updated Oct 28, 2026: On Oct. 26 Judge Reyes granted a preliminary injunction barring further tree removal and requiring 10 business days' notice of irreparable changes, finding the government likely violated NEPA. Trump says Interior will appeal. Status changed from Pending to Ruled.
  • Updated Oct 20, 2026: Judge Reyes rejected the Justice Department recusal request and questioned Interior officials at an Oct. 19 hearing. The underlying challenge remains pending.
  • Updated Oct 17, 2026: On Oct. 16 Justice asked Judge Reyes to recuse herself over alleged bias in the tree removal case; the merits of the lawsuit remain pending.
  • Updated Oct 16, 2026: On Oct. 13 Judge Reyes extended the order barring further tree removal until at least Oct. 26 and set an Oct. 19 hearing to question Interior and Park Service officials about who approved the cutting. Status unchanged (Pending): the order preserves the status quo.

What happened

The D.C. Preservation League and two local golfers are suing the Interior Department over the overhaul. Their complaint, filed in February 2026, says the project violates the 1897 law that created East Potomac Park for 'recreation and the pleasure of the people', skips the environmental review the National Environmental Policy Act requires by splitting the work into smaller pieces, and damages a park on the National Register of Historic Places; it also says the Park Service began dumping debris from the demolished White House East Wing onto the course in October 2025.

In December 2025 Interior ended the lease of the National Links Trust, the nonprofit that had run the course and two others and says it spent $8.5 million improving them. On Friday, Oct. 9, shortly before 5 p.m., government lawyers told the court that tree removal would start the next day; the course superintendent's declaration, filed at 4:37 p.m., said 169 trees would come down first, then 90 more, for an estimated 529 in all.

On Saturday crews felled 430 trees by the government's count; the plaintiffs say all 529 came down, including healthy mature oaks and maples. Rain stopped the work on Sunday, and about 99 more trees were flagged for removal. The superintendent, Kevin Griess, said none of the 430 had been identified as hazardous.

On Sunday the plaintiffs asked for an emergency order after Justice Department lawyers told them the operation was moving faster than anticipated and hundreds more trees could be cut soon. At a hearing of nearly four hours on Monday, Oct. 12, Judge Ana Reyes ordered Griess to testify under oath and questioned a Park Service deputy director, Frank Lands; both said there had been no urgency to cut the trees on Saturday.

Griess said he sent the tree plan to the head of the Park Service on Oct. 5, that it was approved the next day, that it carries out a 2019 cultural landscape report calling for a links-style course with few trees, and that the work went ahead once money and staff were freed up after the Freedom 250 Grand Prix in August. Reyes told the government's lawyer that it had 'lost credibility', said she was furious and that ignorance was not an excuse, and said the government had meant to act without warning the plaintiffs or the court.

Where it stands

On Monday, Oct. 26, 2026, Judge Ana Reyes granted a preliminary injunction in a 70-page opinion. It bars the Interior Department and the Park Service from removing or damaging more trees at the course and requires at least 10 business days' written notice before any irreparable change to East Potomac Park while the case goes on. She found the government likely violated the National Environmental Policy Act by splitting the renovation into smaller projects, an approach she called 'chop-first, review-later', said the Justice Department's description of the cutting as routine maintenance conflicted with Trump's announcement of a championship course, and rejected the argument that the order intrudes on the president's authority, since it is aimed at the agencies.

It is a preliminary ruling, not a final decision. Trump said Interior will appeal, asked the D.C. Circuit for immediate relief and said the course will still close on Nov. 15 for renovation. Before the ruling, Reyes had kept further cutting barred with short temporary orders after the Oct. 10 felling, said the government had lost credibility with her, and on Oct. 19 rejected the department's request that she recuse herself and heard testimony from Interior officials about who approved the work.

On Oct. 27, the administration filed an appeal in the D.C. Circuit, without requesting an immediate stay in that filing. In an Oct. 28 court submission, Justice Department officials said Interior was developing a plan to close the course by Nov. 15. The preliminary injunction remains in place, and the underlying lawsuit is ongoing. At an Oct. 30 hearing Reyes opened a formal inquiry, possibly led by a special master, into whether agency officials and Justice Department lawyers misrepresented facts to the court, after the government acknowledged a plan for a championship course and a wider park closure that its lawyers had for months said was not final; she said opening the inquiry is not a finding of any violation.

She has also required 10 days' written notice before the course is closed or irreversibly changed, and the government has appealed both of her orders. On Nov. 7, 2026, Reyes gave notice that she intends to appoint Jessie Liu, U.S. attorney for the District of Columbia in Trump's first term, as special master to examine whether Justice and Interior Department lawyers and officials committed ethical violations or misled the court.

The administration's side

Interior's press office says it does not comment on pending litigation. When it ended the nonprofit's lease, the department said the group had not made the capital improvements its lease required and that it would keep the courses safe, open, affordable and accessible. Government lawyers described the work as a tree management and cultural landscape rehabilitation project, and the superintendent testified that it carries out the 2019 report's recommendations for the course's original links-style design, which decades of changes had obscured.

Justice Department lawyers told the judge they had not known the details of the tree-cutting plan. At the Oct. 13 hearing the government said the removal was part of a 2019 plan to remove dead, dying and hazardous trees, and that it had done its best to provide notice. In its Oct. 16 motion, the department alleged that the judge had treated its attorneys unfairly and displayed hostility toward the administration.

Trump called the Oct. 26 ruling unconstitutional and wrote that the notice requirement is 'time-consuming, unnecessary, expensive, and unconstitutional'. At the Oct. 30 hearing, Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward Jr. said he knew of no corrections to make, that Trump's posts direct agencies to act but do not guarantee it will happen, and that the government would never violate the court's order. The Interior Department responded to the special master notice by calling Reyes a 'far-left activist judge'.

Sources

See it in the timeline

Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/eastpotomac/