The RecordExhibit 95
Firing the election commission's Democrats before the midterms
Criticized means: Legal, or a policy choice, but widely condemned.
On July 9, 2026, four months before the midterms, Trump fired the Election Assistance Commission's two Democratic commissioners, Thomas Hicks and Benjamin Hovland, by email and asked the remaining Republican, Christy McCormick, to resign, which she did. The fourth seat had been empty since Republican Donald Palmer left in April, so the commission was left with no members.
Updated Oct 11, 2026: Added ProPublica's report: the Bipartisan Policy Center, a nonpartisan group, called the departures a significant loss for an institution built on bipartisan governance, and Hovland learned of his firing by email while visiting an election office. Status unchanged (Criticized).
Earlier changes to this entry (1)
- Corrected Oct 7, 2026: The entry had an approximate date and one advocacy source. The firings were on July 9, 2026; the remaining Republican resigned and the fourth seat was already empty, leaving no commissioners. Added news sources, the critics on record and the White House's reason.
What happened
The small bipartisan agency, created by the Help America Vote Act after the 2000 election, certifies voting equipment and the labs that test it, maintains the national mail voter registration form, administers election grants and issues guidance to state and local election offices; it has no enforcement power. It cannot conduct official business until the Senate confirms at least three new commissioners. It went without a quorum from 2010 to 2014 and again until 2019.
Where it stands
No court has ruled and no lawsuit has been reported; the dismissed commissioners have not said whether they will sue. Sen. Alex Padilla and Rep. Joseph Morelle, the top Democrats on the committees that oversee elections, said Trump was trying to erode trust in elections, and Democratic secretaries of state said election officials would have to fill the gap.
UCLA election law professor Rick Hasen told Votebeat it is unclear whether the Supreme Court's June 2026 ruling on removals at independent agencies extends to bipartisan bodies like the commission. The Bipartisan Policy Center, a nonpartisan think tank, called the departures a significant loss for an institution designed around bipartisan governance, ProPublica reported, and Hovland, who learned of his firing by email while visiting an election office in Missouri, said the commission had been working in a bipartisan way to support election officials. The objections on the record come from Democrats, from experts who question the legal basis and from that nonpartisan group; we found no Republican official objecting.
The administration's side
A White House official said the president reserves the right to remove people who may not be fully aligned with securing elections, and that the Supreme Court's June 29, 2026 decision in Trump v. Slaughter, which upheld the firing of a Federal Trade Commission member, gave him the precedent to do so.
Sources
Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/eac/