The wire About & Methodology All entries

The RecordExhibit 8

Checks & balances

DOGE gets into Americans' Social Security records

Mixed rulingsUpdated Oct 28, 2026Checked Nov 4, 2026

Mixed rulings means: Courts have ruled both ways on parts of it.

Musk's DOGE team pushed into Social Security systems holding Social Security numbers, bank, tax and medical data for nearly everyone in the country.

Updated Oct 28, 2026: On Oct. 20 Judge Denise Cote ruled that OPM unlawfully gave DOGE staff broad access to federal workers' personnel records. Status unchanged (Mixed): that ruling is about OPM, not Social Security.

What happened

The acting SSA commissioner resigned rather than hand the data over. The agency's chief data officer later filed a whistleblower complaint saying DOGE copied records on more than 300 million Americans to a cloud server without proper oversight. In a later court filing, the Justice Department admitted a DOGE staffer shared data through an unapproved server, that DOGE kept accessing data while a court order barred it, and that a DOGE employee had a secret agreement with a political advocacy group.

Where it stands

In April 2025 Senior Judge Ellen Lipton Hollander of the U.S. District Court in Maryland blocked the access with a preliminary injunction, as a likely Privacy Act violation, writing that DOGE never gave a single reason it needed everything. The Supreme Court lifted that block in June 2025 in an emergency order, over three dissents.

On April 10, 2026, the full 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals vacated the Maryland judge's injunction and sent the case back to her, with a majority deferring to the Supreme Court's order. The majority opinion found that the unions have standing to sue, and the lower court could still order DOGE employees to destroy any illegally obtained data. None of these rulings is a final decision on whether the access was legal. The case is back before Hollander, where the administration moved in May 2026 to dismiss it.

On Sept. 29, 2026, the Government Accountability Office reported on DOGE teams at six other agencies (the CFPB, Education, NOAA, the SEC, the SBA and the VA). Four of them reported that the teams had access to more than 23 systems, which held sensitive information including personal data; the SBA and the VA did not say which systems their teams could reach.

The GAO said it could not determine what the teams were allowed to do in those systems, and that without the records it asked for, Congress and the public lack assurance the information was properly secured. The review did not include the Social Security Administration. In a related case about federal workers' records, Judge Denise Cote ruled on Oct. 20, 2026, that the Office of Personnel Management unlawfully gave DOGE staff broad access to systems holding sensitive data on tens of millions of federal employees without showing a need for the records, and bypassed safeguards on privileged access.

She granted the plaintiffs summary judgment on their Administrative Procedure Act claims and has not yet decided on a remedy; OPM has since rescinded the permissions and adopted new procedures. That ruling concerns OPM, not Social Security, so the stamp is unchanged.

The administration's side

DOGE said full access was needed to root out fraud and improper payments, including payments to dead people. Of the six agencies in the GAO review, five offered no comments on the report and the CFPB said it had concerns about its accuracy; the GAO said it stands by its facts. In the OPM case the government argued that DOGE staff needed broad access to carry out modernization work under the president's executive orders, and that OPM's new access procedures make further relief unnecessary.

Sources

See it in the timeline

Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/doge/