The RecordExhibit 57
More than 500 U.S. citizens held by immigration agents
Alleged means: Serious, credible accusations of illegality that no court or watchdog has decided yet.
ProPublica has documented more than 500 American citizens detained by immigration agents since January 2025, some kicked, tased, beaten, held at gunpoint or kept for days without a lawyer, and about a dozen of them deported. Its first count, published in 2025, found more than 170.
Updated Oct 10, 2026: ProPublica's count of U.S. citizens detained by immigration agents, published Oct. 6, now stands at 506 from January 2025 through September 2026, about a dozen of them deported. The headline and summary carry the new figure. DHS says its operations are targeted. Status unchanged (Alleged).
Earlier changes to this entry (1)
- Updated Oct 7, 2026: On Oct. 5 a federal judge in New York ruled that ICE's Bronx arrests of a Dominican immigrant and a 19-year-old U.S. citizen were illegal, and found agents falsified records and gave testimony with the hallmarks of coordinated fabrication. Status unchanged (Alleged): the ruling covers one operation.
What happened
The Oct. 6, 2026 count, covering January 2025 through September 2026, lists 506 citizens. More than 100 were held after agents questioned their citizenship, nearly all of them people of color; about 300 were detained for allegedly assaulting or obstructing agents, of whom 137 were charged with federal crimes, and nearly half of those charges were dropped or dismissed; at least 63 were detained while recording agents; 36 were held for at least a day without access to a lawyer or family; and at least 70 were children or teenagers, about 20 of them handcuffed or zip-tied.
About a dozen citizen children were deported with their parents, allegedly over the parents' objections, and one adult, Brian Morales Garcia of Texas, was held for four days without being able to contact anyone and deported to Mexico in the spring; he was allowed back in September after suing. Each incident needed at least two sources, and the count leaves out airports, border areas and arrests under judicial warrants.
ProPublica calls it almost certainly an undercount, noting that witnesses estimated more than 200 citizens were detained in one Idaho raid where it could identify 30. The 2025 count found at least three of the citizens were pregnant. The government does not track how often its agents detain citizens; ICE told Congress that 131 citizens were arrested during the Minnesota surge for assault, obstruction or interference, more than ProPublica could catalog.
Where it stands
On Dec. 9, 2025, Senate Democrats led by Sen. Richard Blumenthal published a report, based on interviews with nearly two dozen citizens, that concluded immigration agents have frequently detained and mistreated Americans; one was held for four days. It is a report by one party's senators, not an official finding. The Supreme Court had earlier allowed agents in the Los Angeles area to consider factors including race.
On Oct. 5, 2026, U.S. District Judge Gary Brown of the Eastern District of New York, a Trump appointee, ruled in the habeas case of Angel Almonte that ICE's May 6 arrests of Almonte and of Jeury Concepcion, a 19-year-old U.S. citizen, on a Bronx street were procedurally deficient and legally invalid. Agents said they had mistaken both men for a deportation target who, by ICE's own records, stood 5 feet 7 and weighed 110 pounds; Almonte is listed at 6 feet and 180 pounds.
Brown found that the administrative warrant was substantially false, that a supervisor whose database searches found nothing then entered information so a second search would 'find' Almonte, that the team leader admitted a sworn certificate of service was false, and that three officers' testimony about seeing Almonte sell drugs bore 'all the hallmarks of coordinated fabrication'; no drugs or cash were found and the arrest report mentioned no drug sale.
Video showed a masked agent approaching Concepcion with a gun drawn, and he needed stitches for head wounds. The ruling is not a criminal finding of perjury. Brown gave ICE 21 days to explain what steps it will take and said he could then consider sanctions, referrals to other authorities or contempt proceedings. The ruling concerns one operation, so this entry's status is unchanged.
The administration's side
DHS says it does not arrest or deport U.S. citizens and that citizens it detained were interfering with or assaulting officers. It repeated after the Senate report that it does not arrest citizens for immigration enforcement. Homeland Security did not respond to requests for comment on the Almonte ruling. Responding to the October 2026 count, DHS said its enforcement operations are highly targeted and that it does its due diligence, that it is not arresting citizens by mistake, that anyone who obstructs agents will face consequences including arrest, that ICE does not zip-tie or restrain children, and that parents are asked whether they want to be removed with their children or to place them with someone they designate. It said there were no administrative arrests of citizens during the Chicago surge.
Sources
Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/citizens/