The wire About & Methodology All entries

The RecordExhibit 83

Immigration & policing

Waiving dozens of laws to wall off Big Bend

Mixed rulingsUpdated Nov 14, 2026

Mixed rulings means: Courts have ruled both ways on parts of it.

Homeland Security waived dozens of environmental, historic preservation and land laws to build border barriers and roads across Texas's Big Bend region, later extending the waivers to the national park itself.

Updated Nov 14, 2026: On Nov. 9 the Supreme Court paused Judge Cardone's order, letting Big Bend construction resume while the cases continue. Status unchanged (Mixed).

Earlier changes to this entry (2)
  • Updated Oct 28, 2026: On Oct. 21 the administration asked the Supreme Court to lift Judge Cardone's order halting border wall construction in the Big Bend region. Status unchanged (Mixed).
  • Corrected Oct 11, 2026: On Oct. 8 the government asked Judge Cardone to suspend her injunction while it seeks Supreme Court review, saying a 1996 law routes the challenge there. The entry had said an appeal would go to the Fifth Circuit; that was wrong. Status unchanged (Mixed).

What happened

The February waiver called the region an area of high illegal entry, but a coalition opposing the wall points out that Border Patrol made only 151 apprehensions across the entire 517-mile sector in January 2026.

After public backlash, the border agency's commissioner said in May there would be no wall in Big Bend; about a week later the agency awarded a $1.7 billion construction contract for the region, and a June waiver covered the national park. Ranchers, sheriffs, former park superintendents and environmental groups oppose the project, much of which would be built on private land. Opponents say bulldozing began in August.

Where it stands

Two judges of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas have ruled differently, both at the preliminary stage. On Sept. 30, 2026, Judge Orlando Garcia declined to issue an emergency order in one case, which let construction proceed.

On Oct. 2, Judge Kathleen Cardone, a George W. Bush appointee sitting in El Paso, granted a preliminary injunction in a separate case. It halts barrier construction across the more than 500-mile Big Bend sector and puts the waivers on hold, on a finding that opponents are likely to prove at least one of their claims. Neither is a final ruling, and the lawsuits continue.

On Oct. 8 Homeland Security and Customs and Border Protection asked Judge Cardone to suspend her order while the solicitor general seeks Supreme Court review, saying that a 1996 immigration law sends challenges to such orders directly to the Supreme Court rather than to an appeals court, that the pause is costing the border agency at least $462,800 a day and that pulling workers and equipment off five projects would cost about $7 million.

The filing calls the harm to the national park speculative because the agency is considering scaling the project back, and asks the judge for a written opinion explaining her order. The plaintiffs in that case, the Center for Biological Diversity, the Friends of the Ruidosa Church and a local river guide, say the judge has already heard and rejected those arguments. Six lawsuits have been filed.

On Oct. 21, 2026, the administration filed an emergency application asking the Supreme Court to lift Judge Cardone's Oct. 2 order, which the AP describes as a preliminary injunction halting construction across the roughly 500-mile project area; she found the plaintiffs likely to succeed on their claim that the waivers exceeded the Homeland Security secretary's authority under the major questions doctrine.

On Nov. 9, 2026, the Supreme Court granted the administration's request to put Judge Cardone's order on hold, which lets construction resume, but denied its request to reverse her ruling summarily; only Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson indicated she would have denied the request. The order is not a ruling on the merits, and the lawsuits continue.

The administration's side

The administration says barriers are needed even in remote areas to achieve what it calls operational control of the border, meaning no unauthorized crossings. Border officials have said current plans do not include a 30-foot wall inside the national park, and the agency is considering scaling the project back.

Administrations of both parties have used these waivers to speed wall construction. In its Supreme Court application the government says Big Bend is an area of high illegal entry and that a 1996 law gives the secretary broad power to waive laws to build barriers and roads near the border.

Sources

See it in the timeline

Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/bigbend/