The wire About & Methodology All entries

The RecordExhibit 28

Immigration & policing

'Alligator Alcatraz' in the Everglades

Mixed rulingsUpdated Oct 28, 2026

Mixed rulings means: Courts have ruled both ways on parts of it.

A detention camp for immigrants was thrown up in the Florida Everglades as a showcase for Trump's deportation push; Trump joked that escapees would have to learn to dodge alligators.

Corrected Oct 28, 2026: The entry said the detention center stays open. It closed in June 2026: ICE moved all detainees out in mid-June, citing hurricane season, and DeSantis announced the closure on June 25. Status unchanged (Mixed).

Earlier changes to this entry (1)
  • Corrected Oct 6, 2026: The stamp was Ruled unlawful and the entry said only that an appeals panel had paused the judge's order. It had missed the Eleventh Circuit's April 21, 2026 ruling, 2 to 1, that the state-run facility did not need a federal environmental review. The stamp is now Mixed rulings.

What happened

Reporting found many detainees held there had no criminal history.

Where it stands

Courts have ruled both ways. In August 2025 U.S. District Judge Kathleen Williams in Miami issued a preliminary injunction ordering the facility wound down within 60 days because no federal environmental review was done. Florida appealed to the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals, which paused her order in September 2025.

On April 21, 2026, a panel of that court ruled 2 to 1 against the injunction: the majority found that the Florida-run facility was not under federal control and so did not need a federal environmental review. Judge Nancy Abudu dissented, writing that the facility could not have been built and used without the federal government's request.

Both rulings came at the preliminary stage. The lawsuit continues in the trial court. The detention center itself has closed: ICE moved all detainees out in mid-June 2026, citing hurricane season, and on June 25, 2026, Gov. Ron DeSantis announced at the site that it had closed, saying it was always meant to be temporary until federal officials had enough permanent capacity.

The administration's side

DHS blamed an activist judge for blocking removal of the worst of the worst. Gov. DeSantis said you either have a country or you don't. Announcing the closure, DeSantis said the state stepped up because there was a gap and that 21,000 people were deported through the facility.

Sources

See it in the timeline

Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/alcatraz/