The RecordExhibit 103
Immigration agents shooting people in cars
Pending means: In court or under criminal investigation right now.
An ICE agent in Austin shot DoorDash driver Wilber Rafael Garces Perez in the back during a traffic stop. He was moved from the hospital to a detention center with the bullet still in him, then charged with assault.
Updated Oct 16, 2026: A GAO report released Oct. 14 found ICE and CBP officers unsure when to turn on body cameras and recommended automatic activation for unplanned uses of force; DHS rejected that, citing privacy. Status unchanged (Pending).
Earlier changes to this entry (3)
- Updated Oct 11, 2026: Surveillance video obtained by ABC News shows officers approach Belgal's car with guns drawn and one punching through the window as he reversed out; it does not capture the shooting. His petition says he was arrested without a warrant. DHS has not released its body camera footage. Status unchanged.
- Updated Oct 10, 2026: On Oct. 8 an ICE officer fired seven rounds into a car in the Bronx with a 5-year-old in the back seat, wounding the driver, Oscar Belgal. On Oct. 9 a judge barred his removal from the country while his detention challenge is pending. DHS says agents fired in self-defense. Status unchanged.
- Updated Oct 8, 2026: On Oct. 5 Marimar Martinez, the U.S. citizen shot by a Border Patrol agent in Chicago in October 2025, sued the government, alleging the agent fired from behind her car and gave false statements. Status unchanged (Pending).
What happened
In July, ICE agents killed Lorenzo Salgado Araujo at a Houston traffic stop and Johan Sebastián Durán Guerrero in Biddeford, Maine. Before Austin, a CNN analysis counted at least 20 people shot by ICE and Border Patrol agents this term, eight of them fatally, nearly all in vehicles. NBC News reported the ICE officer who shot Garces Perez had been issued a body camera but wasn't wearing it.
Where it stands
The Travis County district attorney and Maine's attorney general are investigating. The DA asked DHS to pause Garces Perez's deportation during its probe. In late September a judge temporarily halted Garces Perez's deportation, and Austin police said they had not received the evidence they asked federal investigators for.
On Sept. 30, ICE told its deportation officers in a memo obtained by the AP that they may not chase vehicles that fail to pull over under any circumstances, that only officers who have completed specific training may make vehicle stops, and that every officer at a stop must wear an activated body camera. The AP counts more than a dozen vehicle stops since last year in which ICE agents fired their guns, killing at least four people. Court testimony the same day in the Austin case showed that the two officers involved would not have complied with the new rules.
On Oct. 5, 2026, Marimar Martinez, a U.S. citizen shot by a Border Patrol agent in Chicago on Oct. 4, 2025, sued the federal government under the Federal Tort Claims Act. Her suit says the agent, Charles Exum, fired five shots in under a second, that the fifth came from behind her car, that she suffered seven gunshot wounds, and that his statements to the FBI were false; prosecutors had charged her with ramming his vehicle and dropped the case within a month. Customs and Border Protection told the AP that Exum is on administrative leave and that use-of-force incidents are reviewed by an independent board.
On Oct. 8, 2026, an ICE officer fired seven rounds into a car in the Marble Hill neighborhood of New York City during an attempt to arrest Oscar Belgal, 28, a Dominican national, striking him in the neck below the left ear, according to the New York Police Department; his 5-year-old son was in the back seat and was not hurt. ICE says agents had blocked the car in, that Belgal refused to get out and accelerated toward agents, striking two ICE vehicles, and that a bullet or fragment struck him superficially.
His lawyers told a federal judge the next day that a bullet was still lodged in his body and that they had been unable to find him for most of a day after ICE moved him from a hospital to a facility in New Jersey.
On Oct. 9 U.S. District Judge Paul Oetken in Manhattan ordered that Belgal not be removed from the country without a court order while his petition challenging his detention is pending, and that he not be moved outside the New York and New Jersey federal districts without the court's approval. Surveillance video obtained by ABC News shows Belgal backing into a parking space, two plainclothes officers approaching with guns drawn, Belgal reversing out as one officer punches through the driver's window, and the car driving out of view; the cameras did not capture the shooting or the moment DHS says he drove at agents.
His lawyers' petition says ICE arrested him without a warrant and never issued a notice to appear. As of Oct. 9 DHS had not released its officers' body camera footage, and the FBI and Homeland Security Investigations were investigating jointly. Mayor Zohran Mamdani said he spent two hours on the phone with Trump and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin and failed to win Belgal's release; he and Gov. Kathy Hochul demanded answers, and Sen. Chuck Schumer called for the body camera footage to be released and for independent investigations.
Belgal has a 2023 grand larceny conviction and a pending drug charge, according to the police commissioner, and DHS says he is affiliated with a gang. Tallies by the New York Times and ABC News cited by Time count more than 20 people shot by federal immigration agents this term, at least six of them killed.
On Oct. 14, 2026, GAO released a report, requested by Democratic members of Congress and covering February 2025 to September 2026, finding that some ICE and CBP officers were unsure when to activate their cameras, that one ICE office had not begun using them even after training, and that neither agency had updated the plans overseeing its program as staffing grew; it recommended uniform activation and automatic activation for unplanned uses of force.
DHS rejected automatic activation, saying cameras that start when a weapon is drawn or a siren sounds could record sensitive encounters with informants or victims, and said all ICE offices had cameras by Aug. 5 with training still under way. The report did not examine the Good or Salgado Araujo shootings.
The administration's side
DHS says Garces Perez rolled up his window and drove away, striking an agent with his car. Homeland Security described the memo as a guidance reminder and said vehicle stops and arrests continue. Of the Bronx shooting, DHS says the officers believed their lives and the public's were in danger when Belgal accelerated toward them, that they did not know a child was in the car, and that Belgal put the child at risk by trying to flee. Mullin said the officers wore body cameras and that the footage will be released, and said ICE enforcement in New York would continue.
Sources
- CNN (Sept. 22)
- CNN (Sept. 20)
- Newsweek
- NYT via GV Wire
- Boston Globe
- NBC News
- Texas Tribune via KPRC
- KXAN
- AP via KPRC (ICE memo)
- AP via WBAP (ICE memo)
- AP via Washington Times (ICE memo)
- AP via WDIV (Martinez lawsuit)
- Al Jazeera (Bronx shooting)
- Time (Bronx shooting)
- Courthouse News (Belgal's lawyers)
- Fox News (Judge Oetken's order)
- ABC News (surveillance footage)
- AP via News4Jax (GAO body camera report)
Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/agentshootings/