The wire About & Methodology All entries

The RecordExhibit 105

Elections

Taxpayer-funded TV ads praising Trump before the midterms

Ruled unlawfulUpdated Nov 6, 2026

Ruled unlawful means: A court ruled against it. Some rulings are on appeal.

Weeks before the November elections, the administration began airing TV spots celebrating Trump, labeled 'Paid for by the U.S. Government' and paid for from a $20 million Homeland Security contract. On Oct. 11, 2026, a federal judge in New York ordered the ads stopped, finding it likely that paying for them with border security money was unlawful.

Updated Nov 6, 2026: Added the Social Security and IRS mass emails praising Trump, sent Oct. 29 to 31, which legal experts say could violate the Hatch Act. No complaint or ruling on the emails yet. Status unchanged (Ruled).

Earlier changes to this entry (8)
  • Updated Nov 4, 2026: On Oct. 30 Judge Rochon ordered three ads pulled from government sites and social media and barred their distribution through MAGA Inc. Status unchanged (Ruled).
  • Updated Oct 28, 2026: On Oct. 28 Judge Loren AliKhan, in the DNC's case, barred the government from making and airing the ads with taxpayer money through Nov. 11. Status unchanged (Ruled).
  • Updated Oct 16, 2026: On Oct. 15 Judge Rochon extended her order blocking the ads past the midterm elections, after the plaintiffs said they kept airing, and set a Nov. 4 hearing on a longer injunction. NPR found nearly $10 million spent after Trump said a super PAC would pay. Status unchanged (Ruled).
  • Updated Oct 12, 2026: On Oct. 11 and 12 Judge Jennifer Rochon in New York ordered the ads stopped, finding the plaintiffs likely to succeed on their claim that paying for them with border security money was unlawful. Status changed from Pending to Ruled unlawful, on a two-week restraining order, not a final ruling.
  • Updated Oct 8, 2026: On Oct. 7 a second lawsuit, by Common Cause, a union local and an Alabama candidate, was filed in federal court in New York, and the AP reported that a fifth taxpayer-funded ad aired the same day. Status unchanged (Pending).
  • Updated Oct 7, 2026: On Oct. 7 the Democratic National Committee sued in federal court in Washington to have the ads declared illegal and to stop further taxpayer-funded airings. Status changed from Alleged to Pending: there is now an active lawsuit over the spending.
  • Updated Oct 6, 2026: On Oct. 6 a White House official said Trump does not plan to repay the money taxpayers already spent. Asked himself, Trump said that would be decided. Sen. Chuck Schumer asked GAO and the Office of Special Counsel to investigate. Status unchanged (Alleged).
  • Updated Oct 6, 2026: On Oct. 5 Trump said he would stop using taxpayer money for the ads and have the super PAC MAGA Inc. pay instead. Status unchanged (Alleged): nothing has ruled on the money already spent.

What happened

One ad repurposes a 2024 campaign video. Spending laws have banned unauthorized government publicity or propaganda for about 75 years, and GAO has long treated self-aggrandizing or purely partisan messaging as covered. During the 2025 shutdown, agency websites also ran banners blaming Democrats. A second taxpayer-funded video followed in late September.

CNN also reported tens of thousands of taxpayer dollars spent on a campaign showcasing Kristi Noem shortly before she left office. Federal records show the budget office approved releasing $20 million to Customs and Border Protection under a commemorative events funding line on Sept. 19, and CBP awarded a $20 million national media campaign contract to an ad firm the next day.

Senate Democrats say the money came from border funding in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. The Wall Street Journal reported that Trump personally pushed for the ads and helped shape them. The ad tracker AdImpact counted more than $2.5 million spent on three spots in a single week. In mass emails sent Oct. 29 to 31, 2026, days before the midterms, to people with online accounts, the Social Security Administration said that under Trump it was 'transforming into a model of excellence', and an IRS email credited his tax cuts; both were signed by Frank Bisignano, who runs Social Security and is the IRS's chief executive.

Several legal experts told the New York Times the emails could violate the Hatch Act and the ban on spending appropriated money on publicity or propaganda, and one likened them to this ad campaign. Newsweek reported no formal complaint about the emails, and neither agency answered requests for comment.

Where it stands

Public Citizen filed a complaint with GAO, the watchdog group CREW asked Homeland Security's inspector general to investigate, and top Democratic appropriators demanded the ads come off the air. Republicans have objected too: Senate Majority Leader John Thune said the ads shouldn't be paid for with taxpayer money, and Sen. Thom Tillis compared them to the advertising of Hungary's former leader Viktor Orban.

Experts say they differ from past public-service campaigns because they don't point viewers to any government program. GAO hasn't ruled. On Oct. 5, 2026, Trump said he would stop using taxpayer money for the ads and pay for them with funds raised for MAGA Inc., the super PAC that supports him. CNN had found at least 13 ads made for the campaign.

On Oct. 6 the White House said Trump's announcement was not about reimbursement, and a White House official told NewsNation that Trump does not plan to repay the money already spent. Asked by reporters that day whether he would repay it, Trump said, 'we'll decide.' By then nearly $12 million worth of the ads had aired, according to AdImpact, out of the $20 million set aside. Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer said Trump must return the money and that he believes having the super PAC cover future costs amounts to illegal coordination.

The same day he asked GAO and the Office of Special Counsel to investigate the spending and the conduct of the federal employees involved. Axios noted that federal law generally bars federal officeholders from directing a super PAC's spending. NBC News reported that senior Customs and Border Protection leaders were cut out of the decision to use their agency's money and learned of it from a news report.

On Oct. 7, 2026, the Democratic National Committee sued Trump, the White House, Homeland Security and the budget office in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, arguing that the spending violates the longstanding ban on using appropriated money for publicity or propaganda, the Antideficiency Act, the Purpose Statute and the Administrative Procedure Act, and asking a judge to declare it illegal and block any further taxpayer-funded airings.

The complaint says the ads ran about 90 times on national networks, at a cost of about $337,000, and at least 2,311 times on local stations, at about $1.4 million, over four days in late September, and that they kept airing with the government disclaimer after Trump's Oct. 5 announcement. That lawsuit is why this entry is now stamped Pending. No court, inspector general or GAO decision has addressed the spending already done.

A Reuters-Ipsos poll published the same day found nearly nine in ten voters think it is inappropriate to use taxpayer money for campaign ads featuring a president or Cabinet member. Later on Oct. 7 a second suit was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York by Common Cause, SEIU Local 32BJ and an Alabama legislative candidate, represented by Democracy Forward and the Campaign Legal Center, against Homeland Security, the budget office and the Executive Office of the President; it cites the publicity-or-propaganda ban in annual spending laws and the Hatch Act and asks the court to stop the spending.

The AP reported that a fifth ad, promoting the operation that captured Nicolás Maduro, aired that day with the notice that the U.S. government paid for it. The Campaign Legal Center also filed a Hatch Act complaint with the Office of Special Counsel. On the night of Oct. 11, 2026, U.S. District Judge Jennifer Rochon of the Southern District of New York, in the Common Cause case, ordered the government to stop the ads at once, and on Oct. 12 she explained why in a 40-page order.

She found the plaintiffs likely to succeed on their claim that using money appropriated for border security on the ads violated the Administrative Procedure Act, wrote that the 'Final Battle' ad is almost identical to a 2024 campaign ad with the funding disclaimer changed from the campaign to the U.S. government, and said it gives no information about Homeland Security's functions. According to Courthouse News, the government did not contest that the ads were paid for with appropriated border security funds or dispute the plaintiffs' claim that this violated the Purpose Act and the appropriations law; it argued only that the case was moot because the ads were ending.

The order is a temporary restraining order that lasts two weeks: the government must cancel any remaining airings and may not enter, renew or expand any agreement for the ads. A hearing on next steps was set for Oct. 13. That order is why this entry is now stamped Ruled. It is a preliminary ruling, not a final one, and no appeal had been reported by Oct. 12; the DNC's separate case in Washington was then still undecided.

By the morning of Oct. 12 the ad tracker AdImpact put the government's spending on five ads at about $21.7 million. NPR's analysis of AdImpact data, published Oct. 13, found nearly $22 million in taxpayer money spent on the five ads since late September, nearly $10 million of it after Trump's Oct. 5 post, and that spots kept airing for hours after the Oct. 11 order with hundreds more into the morning of Oct. 12; a White House official said the government did not get notice from the court in time to cancel the buys and that outside groups will pay for future spots.

After a hearing on Oct. 15 at which the plaintiffs said the ads had kept running, Rochon extended the restraining order past the midterm elections and set a hearing for Nov. 4 on a longer injunction; the Justice Department has put the cost so far at about $19 million.

On Oct. 28, 2026, in the DNC's case, Judge Loren AliKhan barred the administration from making and airing the ads with taxpayer money and ordered the budget office and Homeland Security to stop their distribution, including through third parties, through Nov. 11; she said she was unpersuaded by the department's assurance that it had no more media buys planned after Oct. 11, since the ads kept airing. The Washington Sun reports that Rochon's order now runs through Nov. 20.

On Oct. 30, in the Common Cause case, Rochon expanded her restraining order, directing that three ads ('$5,000 to Americans', 'Every Democrat Voted Against No Tax on Tips' and 'Cost of Socialism') be removed from government websites and social media and that plans to distribute them through third parties, including MAGA Inc., be cancelled; she declined to pull the other ads the plaintiffs challenged and said she could revisit the order after more evidence.

The administration's side

The White House says past presidents ran public-service campaigns too, and that the ad openly says the government paid for it, so it isn't covert. It also argues the videos aren't political because Trump isn't on the ballot. Announcing on Oct. 5 that a super PAC would pay from now on, Trump called the ads 'a positive promotion for our Great U.S.A.' The next day a White House official said his post 'was not referring to reimbursement.'

Trump told reporters the ads are promotion for the country of a kind many presidents have done, and did not commit to repaying the money. The White House did not immediately respond to Axios's request for comment on the lawsuit. In court the Justice Department argued that a restraining order was unnecessary because the conduct would end the next day, and Homeland Security told the court it had no plans to keep running the ads on its budget; a senior department official said in a declaration that the funds were available for commemorating efforts and events related to border security.

After the ruling the White House pointed to Trump's Oct. 5 post calling the ads 'a positive promotion for our Great U.S.A.', and a White House official said they are public service announcements that are clearly not political and carry no call to action. Homeland Security did not respond to requests for comment. A White House official called the Oct. 28 ruling moot, saying the ads are being paid for by outside groups. The White House defends the ads as public service announcements; after the Oct. 30 order spokeswoman Lauren Bis called it a 'lawless order'.

Sources

See it in the timeline

Permanent link: https://unredactedrecord.com/e/ads/